Response to Blog post due Wed Sept 23: Did Mesopotamian scribes have algebra? (And how can we recognize 'rhetorical' and 'syncopated' algebra?)

 General principles before algebra

Any mathematical statement does not necessarily need symbols to be considered general. It can be stated through words, diagrams, tables, or examples.

Ancient Babylonians used to practice mathematics like this in their culture.

Is mathematics all about generalization and abstraction

Mathematics is not only generalization and abstraction. Mathematical activity also includes:

Solving real life problems.

Studying patterns.

Measuring and comparing quantities.

Making predictions. 

Making diagrams.

Making procedures.

Communicating.

Studying why a method works.

Abstract ideas to focus on real results, mathematics often develops through movement between the concrete and the abstract. Therefore, mathematics is both particular and general, as well as both practical and abstract.

General ideas without algebra

Number theory

A general number-theory principle could be stated verbally:

When an even number is added to another even number, it will give an even number.

It could also be demonstrated using counters, geometric arrays, or a table of examples

Geometry

Geometry can express relationships through diagrams and constructions

Calculus

Before symbolic calculus, rates of change could be described through motion, proportions, tables, and geometric approximations

Graph theory

A graph-theory principle could be represented with a network diagram. For example:

In a network of connected locations, a route that uses every connection exactly once can exist only when the number of locations having an odd number of connections is zero or two

Probability

Probability could be explained through repeated trials or equally likely cases:

Rhetorical and syncopated algebra

Students often do pass through stages while algebra like mankind did in history.

Rhetorical algebra

In rhetorical algebra, mathematical relationships are expressed entirely in words.

This resembles early mathematical texts in which procedures were written as verbal instructions rather than equations.

Syncopated algebra

Syncopated algebra uses abbreviations, shorthand, or partial symbols. 

This intermediate stage can make the structure of a problem visible without requiring full fluency with variables and formal notation.

Symbolic algebra

In symbolic algebra, the student writes:

x+13=30

and then:

x=17.

Historical and educational parallels

In my opinion the historical development of algebra and a student’s learning processes are not identical, but the comparison is interesting. Ancient mathematicians often began with concrete problems and verbal procedures. Over time, mathematical writing developed abbreviations and specialized notation, eventually leading to the systems we have today.

Students may similarly move from:

-Drawings, objects and examples.

-Verbal statements.

              -Equations using symbols and variables.

-General symbolic reasoning and proof.

I think modern students do not repeat history in the exact same way because they have access to established notation, teachers, diagrams, and technology that ancient mathematicians did not. However, both historians and modern students must develop the ability to separate a mathematical relationship from one specific example.

Conclusion

Algebraic notation is a powerful language for expressing generality, but it is not the only way to think generally. This suggests that teaching algebra should not treat verbal and visual reasoning as inferior stages to be abandoned.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Integrating history of mathematics in the classroom: an analytic survey

  Before reading this paper my thoughts were that mathematics history can easily be added in education in the classroom but it should be mostly a short thing like a story of a mathematician or a fun fact. I had a worry that it might divert the student's attention from the main path even though it will make the math education more interesting, like elaborating the start of negative numbers, observing how people used to solve problems in old times or understanding the discovery of pythagoras theorem. I did not think that  math history could entirely change the methods of teaching math. One thing that surprised me was the differentiation between ‘developed mathematics’ and ‘mathematics in progress’.It is explained in the article that mathematics is the science of trials and errors developed through centuries rather than the logical finished thing explained in books. I felt connected here with my own experience as a teacher and I learned that mistakes are a part of normal learnin...
Read more

Response to articles for Monday September 21

  Main Idea It is explained in these two articles that the methods we use to measure time have come to us by many different civilizations. Egyptians have thought to construct the 24-hour day, and Sumerians and Babylonians invented the base-60 which shows an hour has 60 minutes and a minute has 60 seconds. How the systems developed The first article elaborates how Egyptians divided daylight and night into 12 parts using sundials and by observing stars. As a result a 24-hour day was produced. But summer hours were longer than winter hours. After that Greek astronomers invented 24 equal-length, 12 hours of daylight and 12 hours of darkness. Equal hours did not become common for ordinary people until mechanical clocks were invented in Europe after many centuries. The Babylonians inherited base 60 number system from the Sumerians and used it positionally, similar to decimal numbers today. The articles suggest several possible explanations for the use of 60: Sixty can be divided evenly b...
Read more